Translate

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Araby

Araby
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 10:22 PM
I agree with the author and appreciate her point if view.  I feel this story is somewhat romantic. On the subject of the lonely quest to the bazaar and a gift for a lady. He wouldn't been interested in the bazaar in the first place without Megan’s sister going off on how cool and magnificent it was. The lonely quest is a very mature and wise way of looking at it because in the end of that whole experiences and experiences to come all he has is himself and only himself. You were born alone and you die alone. The symbolic memory of the priest, funeral and all the lovely memories  he had. The childhood memory of the new girl moving in the a new neighborhood. The guy shared the same kind of memories as a little boy welcoming Megan’s sister and how she knew to his neighborhood. The sister talk his head off about the famous bazaar, after he introduced and befriended her welcoming her to the new neighborhood. After all the talk and excitement about visiting the bazaar and getting a gift to bring back to Meg’s sister, he realizes the bazaar it was not as cool and excited for him.

I definitely feel that this author provided you a new and perhaps deeper understanding of the story. I think its the sometimes lonely, brutal, truthful side of what love and romance is like. He went there alone for the hope to bring something back but maturely saw no real investment or potential investment for an expression of his love for Megan’s sister a stranger with no true regard for him just the potential investment. This lonely but realistic realization leads him to believe that, that wasn't  the love he desires, his love he will share with and for someone one day won’t need to be bought. Also the boy seemed like he wasn't interested in this amazing bazaar because he could not relate to Megan's sister's point of view and fantasy about the place. He was too sheltered of failure with the town and life he learned to live that the shock of how different the Bazaar was didn't make him comfortable it almost seemed like a culture shock to him. He probably also realized by not being interested in the Bazaar he had little to relate and be interested in the girl he loved. Maybe because she was new to the neighborhood he was intrigued but then got suddenly turned off by the end of the night as the bazaar closed down and that's why her choose to buy nothing for her. It makes sense that the only person knowing and dreaming to go to that bazaar was an out of towner who wasn't quite sheltered from the outside world and knew there was so much more she wanted to see and do.
I really enjoyed reading this story and the other one but this was my favorite. Love and the feelings of failure of love can really help bring anyone to maturity and adulthood, its the harsh depth reality that can open anyone’s eyes to seeing the real world. Like I always so though, “Its better to love and beloved then to never love at all.


Re: Araby
by Allen Ghazarian - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 10:55 PM
Alissa,

I agree with you also, romance plays a significant role in Araby. It's the common theme of "how far will you go for love".

Re: Araby
by William O'Neill - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 11:34 PM
The story by Joyce was amazing I thought. Just the way he writes makes me want to sit back and keep reading his work, it's captivating the way he invokes such tension, such uneasiness, reality, and passion in his description of early love and desire. He would be writing a normal plot description, then all of a sudden you would be in the boys head by the end of the paragraph and he would describe the girl's "soft hair" and such. One of the best pieces I have even read.

Re: Araby
by Tara Hall - Sunday, October 7, 2012, 12:28 AM
I like how you mentioned the romance piece in araby. I like how you compared that to growing up. Good job

 


The Rite of Passage

The Rite of Passage
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 10:08 PM
For the "Rocking-Horse Winner" it was a destiney and rite of passage as a man witnessing his degenerate gambleholic father play the horses and hope he doesn’t lose. Of which the boys memory is of winning the race as he races with the horses on his rocking-horse and twistedly defines his memory with the word, "Luck" or "Lucky". I think you shouldn’t chase luck it just fall on your lap. Paul’s passage to adulthood starts when he longer care free and the truth he believed when he was a child contradicts cracks like a broken vase of flowers and there lies the truth he sees about gambling and being lucky. The apple doesn’t fall from the tree. Paul’s defense of luck ultimately  leads to his own death unfortunately proving the same. The hero archetype was portrayed by the father’s unrealistic yet imaginative lucky on winning the horses and large amount of cash for the family saving the day, being a hero, for Paul to follow by. Thats when the Oedipus Complex and conflict theory plays its part as the mother tries to put Paul’s father’s gambling addiction in true perspective as she dreads and hopes that her son doesn’t follow into his father’s footsteps; she instead leads him away which leads him more closer and back to his destiny that he will feed his genetic/nurtured addiction, chase the luck he would only seldom have a taste/glimpse of but never catch until he died of such illnesses just like his father.

In the story, "Araby" the unnamed narrator does his own rite of passage into adulthood by discovering the harsh truth about love, martialism, true love, and how different they are sometimes. Unfortunately for him Megan’s sister loved and fantasized about the bazaar not for him. When he makes this hurtful, frustrating, and aggravating, epiphany he buys nothing, not only feeling the rejection and unwanted from the seller at the Bazaar but from Megan’s sister, as well. The experience of love and loss. The quest for the Holy Grail wasn't successful but he took out of it for life, that carried him into adulthood was a grail enough. He would never want to buy love for anyone, love can't be bought or its not true love.  I can’t imagine how it was to feel so lonely, as he watched all the lights turn off as the bazaar closed and did not have anything to bring home to Meg’s sister must of been so lonely; on top of everything the way that the seller made him feel unwanted. In my opinion he was considered pretty ordinary because all poeple at one point or another been in that kind of situation having to make a decision on if this particular person they feel more whether love or lust is worth winning them over and their love over by buying them something or even buying their love. Even the ordinary discovery on what they want out of love and the right person they believe they should be with for this love they want. Its an ordinary crossroads everyone faces at one point in their life.

Re: The Rite of Passage
by Allen Ghazarian - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 10:47 PM
Alissa,

Your comparison to the holy grail in "Araby" was very good, I completely forgot to include that piece into my analysis but you did a fantastic job at it. Both are very tragic stories that could've turned out a bit better had they had the experience of life.
 
Re: The Rite of Passage
by Eduardo Valladolid - Saturday, October 6, 2012, 11:44 PM
I enjoy your transition between both stories. I especially appreciated how you approached this analysis by calling it a rite of passage. Definitely fitting for both these boys.

The Psychology of Poe

The Psychology of Poe
by Alissa Gray - Thursday, September 27, 2012, 10:26 PM
The story themes reflect Poe's real-life experiences,I feel like this story reflects the theme of secrets, mystery, travel, exploitation, revenge, murders, scandal, Authority, and death by comparing it to his life which was all thee above and more especially when he became famous for his writings. The theme of being the only witness in a murder or tampering with evidence, I’m not sure what's more relative.  The House of the Usher may have showed a theme of depression, illness, gothic, death, murder, revenge, vengeance, lioness, and evil. The house is rottoning and diseased infested just like the narrator's friend, who seems to be part of this gothic Usher family.


The atmosphere reflect the tragedy in his life by portraying The murder, the relationship between the police and Duplin, and Europe are extremely relative to his actual life. I’m sure He was around a lot of death throughout his life. The few females in his life like his mother, aunt, grandparents all died when he was young adolescent and he slept in a morgatory in the formaldehyde room, so morbid and somewhat gothic. His first love had died and then he married his first cousin who had died after a short period time, not sure if he ever had children.


Yes,  the characters (and their actions) somehow mimic his life-long relationships and the one relationship that stands out the most with the police and Duplin. He had a lifelong relationship with the police and/or the investigators because of all the death that had occurred throughout her life.Edgar Allan Poe had a lifelong relationship with a certain friend who plays the narrator in the house of the Usher. I’m sure he had a friend that he felt like was somewhat estranged because he didn’t recognize him anymore from how they knew each other as a child.
It seems like these stories kept his sanity on point whenever he goes through any kind of tragedy, makes sense of it, and cope with it by turning it into a beautifully morbid gothic stories. Someone who comes to mind when thinking of Edgar Allen Poe nowadays it would be Tim Burton.
 

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Emilia Hovakemian - Friday, September  28, 2012, 05:24 PM
That's a very good point! Perhaps his dark writings were a way for him to keep himself "sane." Maybe they were like his own personal diary that he shared with the world, in the hopes that he could understand it, and it would understand him.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Jivan Muradian - Friday, September  28, 2012, 06:45 PM
Good call on likening the atmosphere surrounding the Usher household with the atmosphere that surrounded Poe. I really hadn't thought of it that way, but it makes a lot of sense. I feel like the tragedy that surrounded him kind of pushed him to create these very dark settings, because it was what he was accustomed too through out much of his life. Nice work.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Yajaira Lopez - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 11:39 AM
Alissa, I like how you listed all the themes you found in both stories especially in The House of the Usher. The themes you provided are perfect examples of what Edgar Allan Poe experienced during his lifetime. I also agree with you when you say Tim Burton is a perfect example of someone like Poe today. He does provide a dark creativity in his work.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Courtney Kaplan - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 12:50 PM
I completely agree that Poe's writing was an outlet for his extreme sadness. There is no greater triumph for an artist then to turn physical pain into a form of art. I'm really happy that you mentioned this in your writing, I think it's extremely significant.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Shawn Williams - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 02:17 PM
He seemed strong to write about all of his problems in such elegant stories. I guess stories are made through someones struggles? Depression is a huge theme in his stories and its clear as night when he mentions them.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Megan Zullo - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 03:21 PM
I enjoyed the correlation between the police surrounding him in his life time. I could not figure out why the detectives would be involved in a story and why he would write one of mystery.

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Nicole Moncree - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 05:04 PM
I agree that Poe chose writing as a way to cope with what was going on in his life. Not growing up with your parents can be really tough. And losing the person that you love can be just as devastating. I know writing makes me feel better about a lot of stuff as well. Great job!

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Andrew Shooshtari - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 08:46 PM
I believe that stories and his literary work were contributed by his experiences. He endured tough times all throughout his life and even after. I believe this darkness and troubling times helped contribute to his popularity. I agree that the writing might have been an outlet to help keep him sane. Very interesting

Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Gabrielle Amado - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 11:12 PM
Alissa,

You make some very interesting points, and I think that you do have a point in regards to many of the themes that seem to run through his work. I don't know if I would compare Poe to Usher, I consider him more of the narrator, and Usher is different parts of his life. Food for thought.

 
Re: The Psychology of Poe
Saturday, September  29,
 2012, 11:45 PM
 
Did you find any connection between Roderick Usher, and perhaps the struggles within Poe's own mind?  Poe had a dark childhood and family story, just as the Ushers and their personified house.  Also, Madiline to me very much mirrors the Virginia Clem that Poe lost to illness.

 
Re: The Psychology of Poe
by Clara Herrarte - Saturday, September  29, 2012, 11:55 PM
Alissa,
I do believe that Poe was surrounded by death and I also do believe that this influenced his work very much.

-Clara
 

The Tainted Forest

The Tainted Forest
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, September 22, 2012, 09:01 PM
I chose to discuss the staff for the symbol on the Young Goodman Brown encounters in the forest from the old man’s hands holding the staff into the hands of his own (the turning point of his religion and faith. This staff is very symbolic in of biblical and theological perspective. The detailed carving of the serpent represented the devil’s servant an evil demon so to speak. It is relative to the story of Adam and Eve the offering of the Apple. Eve took it and lost her innocence, gaining shame, guilt, embarrassment all because she gave in to curiosity and temptation. I actually think the Apple has a  relative symbolic connection to the rod/staff.  Goodman Brown’s curiosity got the best of him by leading him to the decision to venture in the forest. I Analyzed the meaning of the symbol as it pertains to a key theme in the story. Losing faith and believing in his religion and questioning it by going against it. Being lead by temptation.

This symbols portrays  the old man is more of a demon than human, almost representing the devil himself or at least one of his minions and as for Goodman Brown by holding the staff he leads himself on the way towards a very evil path.

After the show to the venture Georgia for is in question his faith his savings never been the same I feel like he lost and lonely life is faith in God of shame or after just giving into temptation.

He had a good relationship with his wife having faith in him which represents their faith as a couple and now after returned from the forest of evil his wife had lost whatever fate she had and his life, he was no longer fulfilled.

He seems like his life never recovered after being tainted in the forest and so he hasn't been able to reach true happiness nor the purity ring is Sons of the have been is he had once before because of the fact that he has a screaming in the sand and probably not proud of how much.

Fear of losing faith, walking a different path than his forefathers living the more traditional and conservative Puritan life. For example his father would never walk into the Forest of pleasurable temptation and the Devil him reminds that he is not like his forefathers, he is not pure and orthodox, I think. Another example is how the English Puritans treasured the woman's’ faith overpowering the males lack of faith if there was at anytime. If the wife had faith in her husband it would overpower would save the male and revive his faith. Unfortunately in Goodman Brown’s situation after returning from the forest his wife never redeemed her faith therefore he completely loses his faith and any chance he had to resist the devil. There is a quote from the book which I truly appreciate and it goes, “By the sympathy of your human hearts for sin ye shall scent out all the places—whether in church, bedchamber, street, field, or forest—where crime has been committed, and shall exult to behold the whole earth one stain of guilt, one mighty blood spot.” Which means, in my opinion, once trained you can never be untainted. once you have walked the path of evil there is a certain point where you can’t turn around and go back from it.
 

Re: The Tainted Forest
by Allen Ghazarian - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 10:20 PM
Alissa,

I do agree, this story is very biblical and theological as you mentioned. It seems like every few sentences I read, I was able to make a religious connection to it. You did a great job here at covering all the bases, I enjoyed this.

Re: The Tainted Forest
by Nicole Moncree - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 11:32 PM
I believe that the story is a reflection of Hawthorne's religious beliefs. Throughout the whole story there are a number of biblical references. But only evil seemed to stick out the most. The fact that evil can be all around us, tempting us in any way it can. Great analysis!

Re: The Tainted Forest
by William O'Neill - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 11:51 PM
I really liked when you started discussing his forefathers and the reference to his father. This part in the story was a little chaotic and to pull that out of it was very observant. Maybe the part where his mother would hold him back was showing that the men of Hawthorne's generation were straying further from right and wrong, and the teachings of their upbringings.
 

Re: The Tainted Forest
by Jacob Johnson - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 11:59 PM
 
I agree with the man was symbol of the devil. He led Goodman Brown down the crooked path once he accepted the maple branch that was taken from a tree. This also was a symbol as in the tree of good and evil in the Garden of Eden. Good post!

The Black Veil in the Room

The Black Veil in the Room
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, September 22, 2012, 09:34 PM
I think Clayton’s theories pointing out specific characters and plot points definitely apply to this story. Clayton has an in depth perception of how the story went, practically a philosophically sociological view, I like his aspect and explanation or notion on what the hidden meaning and analysis was. Revendred Hooper had his puritan followers believe that guilt and sin were okay if you keep them hidden from you family and community. In this story Hooper was in denial of is black veil and doesn't want to face the fact that he wears one. He basically finds comfort in the sin/darkness, shame he wears as a black veil while wearing a black veil. It's a conflict of settling and not redeeming himself for the guilt-ridden, dark, and secretive sins he wears above his head. Everything unraveled as Reverend Mr. Clark  pointed out how it wasn’t godly nor puritan like to wear these black veils, that everyone needs to purify/redeem themselves, and take off these black veils of darkness. The followers before Reverend Mr. Clark  spoke up or pointed this out, felt a sense of estranged settling confort by not mentioning the pink elephant in the room  because the black veil that the Reverend Hooper wore made it okay for all the other people to wear their black veil.

Yes, I totally agree with Clayton's assessment -- that Hawthorne's main point is that humanity hides behind a veil. I agree on how how humans  hide from behind a veil and they think it's okay. I also think this is a another good example of diffusion of responsibility, everyone following the leader and no one is to be blamed for the mere fact that everyone is wearing the veil including their reverend (which turns into their society's norm).

All humans, at least in this planet, have a little tiny part of them that live a secret, sinful side. I believe is a balance of that makes humans human and part of it is sin but it's you going out with a purity. Without sin they're in there is no use for charity are for a redemption and for the greater good there needs to be a balance like the moon and the sun darken night it has to be for humans to get maintain their sanity.

Human nature needs a stability, balance, and  questions to fit answers that they stumble upon throughout their lifetime. Sometimes we look at religion as guide on how to place our puzzle full of Q&A together, in order to find the true purpose of why we are here on earth and find peace on where we go there after. Everyone has a reason and plays a part with their life for the overall purpose of life itself. I also want to point out the circle of life and how humanity and human nature evolved.
 

Re: The Black Veil in the Room
by Amy Linsamouth - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 11:09 PM
I agree that Clayton's perception is very deep.  I enjoyed reading the passage as well.  Reverend Hooper was guilty over whatever act he did.

Re: The Black Veil in the Room
by Stanley Hu - Saturday, September  22, 2012, 11:26 PM
I think minister Hooper was trying to show everyone that they were also guilty of sins just like he was. He was just open about it, instead of pretending to be perfect.

Re: The Black Veil in the Room
by Jacob Johnson - Sunday, September  23, 2012, 12:17 AM
I think Hooper was trying to preach through his actions initially. With all the commotion he created he then explained to his fiancee but in doing so she was able to realize her own hidden sin in my opinion and understanding. I agree the human nature needs a balance and it is up to the person to come to grips with how they handle their own convictions or hidden sin. Good post!

Civil Rights

 
 
Civil Rights
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, September 15, 2012, 11:53 AM
English 364OL - The Short Story
Discussion: URLs to Civil Rights Sites
Stories: "Sonny's Blues" & "A Worn Path"

James Baldwin and Eudora Welty display a strong sense of place and heritage, directing our consciences to the inequities in American society.

Both "aim" at unraveling the repressive myths of white society and at healing the estrangement in the lives of black Americans (Cassill & Bausch).For this forum, you need to respond to several items. 

First, please search the Internet for historical and cultural information on the civil rights movement, Martin Luther King, The Harlem Renaissance, the Black Power Movement, etc. As you research the various Internet sites, consider the setting and identity of black Americans during the course of the 20th Century (including each story's setting).  Please post at least two URLS with a brief (5-6 sentence) description of each site.

The Black Power Movement
http://hoover.archives.gov/exhibits/africanamerican/blackpower/index.html

This site is a wonderful URL to check out concerning The Black movement. Within the page that pops up it explains how some Black Americans stood up and gain power (sense of superiority) and pride represent their Black community after being suppressed and discourage violently from doing so in the past. It explains the development and unity of The Black Panther Party during wartime Vietnam and such.

Martin Luther King
http://www.thekingcenter.org/

This site is completely dedicated to the history of the legendary Martin Luther King. From the speech,”I Had a Dream” to where he was born and raise with his preacher father. Picture galore to show the greatness and change he inspired for US and breakthrough of equality amongst race.

The Civil Rights Movement
http://www.nps.gov/nr/travel/civilrights/

This site is wonderful to upkeep on the historical moments that had happen in our past. I really enjoyed going through this site and looking at all the wonderful pictures and moments, as harsh as they seem, we have come a long way from then.
Second, consider Langston Hughes poem "Harlem" in regards to the plight of this week's characters and in regards to your Internet research.

What happens to a dream deferred?

Does it dry up
like a raisin in the sun?
Or fester like a sore—
And then run?
Does it stink like rotten meat?
Or crust and sugar over—
like a syrupy sweet?
Maybe it just sags
like a heavy load.
Or does it explode?

In addition to the initial analysis of your Internet urls, please write a 250 word response to the Hughes poem! 
I think that this poem has is sad and depressing. He looks at a dream so the dark and distant like an illusion or gift he will really never receive just get teased by. The intolerance, racism, and discrimination he has gone through because he is a black american at that time gives him little hope for any of his dreams to come true. For him to even gain hope seems like a distant dream of it’s own. The raisin makes a great symbolism for a dried up dream, if a dream is put on hold or in other words neglected for too long it eventually dies out or as he said,”dries out like a raisin”. That’s extremely deep.  The sweet and edible insinuations are interpreted as ven if the dream is still sweet it’s smaller than it use to be; like a raisin shrunk from how it was which was a well rounded beautiful green or red grape. As the dream shrinks like a grape to a raisin losing sight of the grape, the dreamer loses sight of his dreams and hope. During the time the poem was written in the civil rights/post-WW2 the dreamers happen to be suffering Black Americans. I thought Hughes poem’s last lines were just as symbollicaay vgua and deep all at the same time. Clever and short words to put it. Saying ,”Maybe it just sags, like a heavy load.” Says to me that the dream and hope is getting old and worn out like their clothing and skin or even lost in the heavy load of baggage and enslaved labor that their force to do. The dreams and hopes get lost in the saggy emotional and physical baggage they carried from all this hardship.

You may include both in one post OR you may create separate posts.

Lastly, kindly respond to five (5) of your classmates AFTER you visit their website links!  In your responses to your peers, write at least 3-4 thought-provoking sentences.
Good luck and have fun!
 

Re: Civil Rights
by Yajaira Lopez - Saturday, September  15, 2012, 11:59 AM
The two URLS you provided were really great. The first site provided us readers to explore different sections which I really like. I enjoyed it because we were able to concentrate on that certain event alone instead of reading all of the events at the same time. In the second site I found the exact thing like you did. I as well enjoyed looking at all the pictures and moments. We were able to see what truly happened. In addition, I agree with your interpretation of the dream. It was sad and depressing. It spoke about the feelings after not having any hope in that dream anymore or not being able to go after it. I also agree how this poem had great symbolism.

Re: Civil Rights
by Emilia Hovakemian - Saturday, September  15, 2012, 12:33 PM
I've never really had what I would call a "hero." Since I was a very small child, I've always seen humans as being flawed (I was a strange child!), and therefore I guess I just never created an image of a "hero" in my head. As an adult, though, I've begun to have more "heroes," as I realize that a hero is not a flawless person, it's just one that stands up everyday for what is right. Martin Luther King Jr. has always fascinated me, as I wonder where in the world he ever found that amount of strength and courage. It's incredible to think that someone can look directly in the face of death or imprisonment or injury on a daily basis and still march on. It's pretty incredible.

Re: Civil Rights
by Madison Spielvogel - Saturday, September  15, 2012, 04:27 PM
I agree with you Alissa. This poem is pretty depressing yet provides us with so much history from the civil rights movement. I love your analysis on how "the dream shrinks like a grape to a raisin.." That is very powerful and great deep thinking. My favorite link out of your 3 is the civil rights movement one. I love how it gives us an introduction to it and tells us the conclusion to it as well. Great job!

Re: Civil Rights
by Jivan Muradian - Saturday, September  15, 2012, 06:21 PM
You can definitely feel a sense of lowered morale and a feeling of desperation through the words of the author. However, I felt like there was a brief sense of optimism in the last line of the poem. I found your view on the interpretation the "heavy and sagging" line to be very fitting. The baggage of fighting off such inequalities would definitely result in a depression of sorts.

Re: Civil Rights
by Benjamin Ringgenberg - Saturday, September  15, 2012, 12:09 PM
Good work on finding those relevant URL's.  The Black Power movement is a portion of history that few understand and many should know about.  I too found the King Center online and discovered a wealth of information on Dr. King.  I agree with your idea that the raisin in the sun is a metaphor for a dream denied. Additionally, Hughes certainly represented the worries and frustrations of his people; especially during that period in history (1950's). 

Everyday Use

Picture of Alissa Gray
Everyday Use
 
by Alissa Gray - Saturday, September 8, 2012, 09:20 PM
 
In "Everyday Use," Alice Walker asks us to consider the definition of tradition.  Is tradition defined by speaking and doing, yes of course the tradition can be brought down by many ways speaking and doing is one of the many. There are ways to preserve tradition and how to pass it down both daughters portrayed it in a different ways. I feel like Dee’s way of looking at tradition was like the way the villages especially the elders looked at the lottery tradition, kind of ignorant. Wikipedia defines,” A tradition as a ritual, belief or object passed down within a society, still maintained in the present, with origins in the past.” 

The story's title, “ Everyday Use” helped me define tradition throughout this short story because the quilts were passed down from generation to generation for everyday use and not to keep in a glass frame untouched away from use at all. That is the theme and point of this wholesome story.I like how it was obivious why the quilts belonged with Maggie and how traditional Maggie and her mother were in compariosn to Dee who was educated and tradition in her roots not with her family.

The way that Maggie and mama always got stuck.using these antique treasures when someone else would have it around the house for looks, like Dee would do.  And the same went for the quilts because its traditional for everyday use.

The story narrated by the mother because in my opinion on why it was narrated by the mother was that it was narrated by the mother to give the reader a outlook on the mothers unconditional love for her daughters and the way that she looks at him and her purse at her perspective on the whole situation on traditions it is her that is passing down the traditions your daughter so it would make sense if she would tell than her two daughters would.
 

Re: Everyday Use
by Andrew Shooshtari - Saturday, September 8, 2012, 09:25 PM
I agree with you that the daughters both had different ideas about how tradition was interpreted. Complete opposites, if you ask me. Dee felt that observing the quilt was the best way to uphold tradition whereas Maggie would put the tradition to everyday use and use the quilts for their intended purposes. I had a hard time following the last paragraph but I agree with your statement that Maggie was a bit ignorant as to the true value and meaning of a tradition.

Re: Everyday Use
by Susan Espinoza - Saturday, September 8, 2012, 10:04 PM
im confused whats the theme of the story? everyday use passed down through generations? I think the theme in the story is dichotomy.

Re: Everyday Use
by Jivan Muradian - Saturday, September 8, 2012, 10:11 PM
I also found that the daughters had a completely different view on how the heirlooms should be used in order to honor, and remember, their grandmother. However, I feel as though there isn't always a right way to use an item that's been passed down for so long. It's not as important as to how the item is upheld, but rather the memory attached to the item itself.

Re: Everyday Use
by Jacob Johnson - Saturday, September 8, 2012, 11:59 PM
I agree that the daughters viewed tradition in entirely different ways. Where Maggie may not have an education her viewpoint was more logical and realistic. She would have used the objects for everyday use. Dee on the other hand would have taken the heirlooms and placed them for museum pieces in her home to show off. She would not know how to put them to use or how to hand make a quilt like Maggie. Its true their mother did show her unconditional love despite their differences. Good analysis.